Purpose & Objectives
The purpose of this training is to build on the basic skills we introduced in Level 1 and to give handlers the knowledge they need to help dogs with resource-intensive behavior issues.
- To learn clear and consistent techniques for training our dogs, ensuring that staff and volunteers are trained in the same methods and approaches and veterans are able to help reinforce those methods for new volunteers & staff.
- To use small changes to create big results. Knowing what to do at just the right moment can be the difference between having a successful session with a dog or having a lousy time.
- To provide clear and actionable information that enables staff and volunteers to safely and comfortably manage, support and adopt out dogs with varying behavioral needs.
Dog Body Language
What is the dog saying to you and how are you using that information?
Dogs offer clear communication if we pay attention and learn to understand their language. Reading their body language and responding appropriately is key for both positive reinforcement and prevention of unwanted behaviors.
Promote Appropriate Behavior
Mark and reward behaviors you do want, and soon the dog will repeat them often. When the dog makes a socially appropriate choice and responds to your cues, use the verbal marker “Yes” and reinforce with a resource that dog finds valuable in that moment. Resources may include a treat, toy, affection, play, etc.
- Dog looks away from kennels rather than fence fighting with a neighbor. You, the handler, mark with enthusiastic “Yes,” jog away and give a treat.
Redirect Unwanted Behavior
Most dogs have a “tell” or precursor behavior they do before they do something naughty. Watch the dog closely and redirect potential unwanted behaviors when you see the tell. When dogs practice inappropriate behaviors, those behaviors can become habits difficult to change and likely to escalate.
- Dog who is mouthy when excited turns to you with a glint in her eye. You notice this behavior and toss treats on the ground away from your body or redirect her to a toy.
Reinforce Calming Signals
“Calming Signals” are actions dogs use to diffuse tension or avoid conflict: yawning, licking, turning away, sniffing the ground, play bowing, freezing, sitting, walking in a curve, etc. We can reinforce this body language to promote behavior we want. Watch for these signals, use them to create successful interactions, and reward the dog for making socially appropriate choices.
- Dog walks in a curve and sniffs the ground while returning to her kennel instead of engaging with other barking dogs. Support her by responding to her signals (walk her in a curve and give pause when she needs it) rather than pulling her toward the kennels.
Recognize Eye Contact
Eye contact is an invaluable behavior to reinforce. If a dog checks in with you, he is asking for guidance and approval. When you work with the dog to reinforce his natural tendency to engage with you, you will see these behaviors repeated.
- A dog turns back to look at you when a car passes. You tell her “Yes” and offer a treat. She will be more likely to check in with you when the next car passes.
Doggie Drawings, Lily Chin, http://www.doggiedrawings.net/#!freeposters/ckm8
- On Talking Terms with Dogs, Turid Rugaas, http://www.dogwise.com/itemdetails.cfm?ID=DTB527
- Learning to Speak Dog, Tails from the Lab, http://www.tailsfromthelab.com/2012/05/17/learning-to-speak-dog-a-canine-behavior-series/
Table standing is only for special occasions.
Use the right equipment
Make sure you use any designated equipment when taking a dog out. A secure harness will give you better control over the dog, as well as give the dog him/herself better body awareness. A martingale collar prevents the dog from backing out and getting loose. We also recommend double-clipping Easy Walk Harnesses to the dog’s collar (leash clips both rings) to keep the harness centered on the dog’s chest and prevent them from stepping over it. Always carry treats and at least one toy.
Know where the safety stations are and have a solid idea of how to respond should something go wrong. Below are three scenarios we’d rather not encounter but sometimes do:
Trapped in a kennel
Sometimes, a dog doesn’t want you to leave and uses his mouth or body to keep you there. If you are unable to redirect the dog by other means like a counter command or engaging them in an activity, attach the carabiner clip to the end of their leash and hook it on the kennel so you can exit and get assistance.
- Try to remember to slow down and breathe. Most fights are a lot more noise and flying fur than actual physical damage. Rarely do dogs intend to kill each other or even do much harm, so you have time. Use it to put safety first.
- Yell, “Dog fight! Help!” loud & clear to get a 2nd person to assist you as you move rapidly toward the safety station.
- Try water, citronella spray, and the air horn to break up the fight if possible.
- Do not stick your hands near either dog’s head or attempt to grab the collar; the likelihood you will be bitten is high, even with a dog you know well. Stay behind the dogs, on the periphery of the fight.
- If either dog has a grip on the other, follow these steps to separate them. Always stay alert and consider your safety first:
- Get two leashes (allow the fight to continue while you do this).
- Walk behind one dog and loop the leash under the belly of one dog (in front of the back legs) by threading the leash through the handle.
- Now slowly back away. Drag the dog to a fence or to an object that you can tie the leash to. By doing this, you effectively create an anchor for one of the dogs.
- Then walk around and repeat the step above for the second dog.
- Hold the leash tight and taut, and wait for the dogs to release.
- Then, drag the dog into a dog pen or another room before you release him.
- Go back and take the dog off the fence and put him or her into a dog kennel.
- When it is safe (the dog is no longer aroused/a redirection bite risk), check each dog over for injuries and report any injuries to vet services.
- If two people are available, then modify this protocol so that each person loops a dog up at the same time. Both people back up slightly and hold the leashes tight and taut until the dogs release, and then back up to separate the dogs.
Yell “Loose dog! Help!” loud & clear and then immediately direct your attention to the situation at hand.
- Do not chase, run, or yell at the loose dog.
- Use your body language to be non-threatening and inviting (i.e. use a sing-song voice, walk in a curve, not approach straight on, look at the ground).
- You may also try jogging away in a playful manner to get the dog to follow you, sitting (or even lying) down, or tossing treats to entice the dog.
- Use your judgment whether a slip lead, a collar grab, or luring the dog into a nearby pen works best and contain the loose dog as quickly as possible.
If you are handling another dog when a loose dog situation occurs, try to get your dog inside a pen or enclosed space immediately. If this is not possible, stay calm. Keep the leash your dog is on slack and position yourself confidently between the loose dog and your dog. Toss treats directly at the approaching loose dog to distract it and give you and your dog enough time to retreat.
Naughty dogs need love too.
This is the trickier stuff you’ll encounter in your work with shelter dogs. We highly recommend checking out the continued training opportunities to hone your skills. It’s far more information than can adequately be covered in a single training but we can at least provide you with a cheat sheet!
First: Do the least amount of work necessary to change or modify a behavior. Your response should be proportional to the behavior presented. Prior to working on any of the below behaviors, it is important to have a solid understanding of three things:
- Threshold: Suzanne Clothier explains threshold as the “think and learn zone.” This is the place at which the dog can still make good choices and learn new behavior. In a nutshell, it means your dog is not too stressed to learn but not so far removed from the stimulus that he/she lacks the opportunity to learn. The situation may be challenging but remains a positive experience that builds confidence, and is not so stressful that it creates or reinforces a negative association.
- Dog Body Language: We’ve mentioned this already but it is worth repeating. You can’t effectively use threshold if you don’t understand how your dog is feeling. Understanding and accurately reading dog body language is a critical component in training.
- Motivation & Goal: What specific behavior are we talking about? What is causing a given behavior? What behavior do we want to reinforce instead? Consider what role the dog’s individual personality, the environment, specific stimuli, and the handler may be playing in the behavior. Finally, what is going to be rewarding for your dog in this training scenario and what skills can you offer him/her so that s/he can navigate the situation safely and successfully?
Common, Unwanted Behaviors and How to Change Them
This is typically the dog who is super excited to see you and do all the things. While some of us enjoy this behavior and might greet our dogs at home this way, we discourage this behavior in shelter dogs because it is usually considered bad manners and can be a barrier to adoption.
The two simplest ways to stop jumping are:
- Turn your back to the jumper.
- Ask for a counter command (in this case, sit).
The dog gets attention when he is sitting but loses the interaction with his super exciting human when he jumps. This same thing applies when greeting people other than the handler. If you are in the role of handler when a new person comes up, ask your dog to sit for greeting and walk him away if he jumps, explaining to the new person that the the dog is in training to help him get adopted and practicing good greeting manners. For some dogs, simply stopping the walk for a moment stops the jumping. Using time outs is typically not necessary for jumping behavior but is an available tool in extreme cases.
For jumpy dogs, working the Relaxation Protocol can be great practice for polite greeting and interaction behavior. There is often overlap between jumpy dogs and energetic dogs. When that’s the case, these pups would thank you for a nice jog or a hike to get some of their physical energy out as well!
This is anytime dog teeth touch human skin or clothing. Mouthing can be the result of dogs removed from their mothers and/or littermates too early and not learning appropriate play behavior or not understanding the difference between play with dogs and play with humans. It can also be a symptom of a dog who is stressed, overstimulated, or frustrated.
When dealing with mouthing, STAY CALM. You can unintentionally reinforce or escalate the behavior by becoming excited or overly animated. The technique you use to redirect and modify mouthing will depend on what works best with a given dog.
- Try removing yourself from the situation. If you are sitting, stand. If you are standing, turn away. If you need to remove yourself from a kennel, pen, or room do so.
- Some dogs can be redirected by asking them to perform an incompatible behavior like sit or touch/target.
- Others will redirect well to an appropriate object like a toy.
- Some dogs do better engaging in an activity or game that gets them moving forward like toss the treat or go find.
- Walking the dog through some simple obstacles like cones or an agility ladder can help break the fixation and channel energy somewhere positive.
- You may also try bringing the energy level down by becoming still and using gentle touch or TTouch to help the dog calm.
If none of these work and the situation may become unsafe for you and the dog, use a time out.
If you cannot redirect the dog to an appropriate behavior, then the dog is usually over threshold and needs help to calm the down. Use a sturdy carabiner clip to attach the dog to something secure (a tree, fence, etc.) and walk away. When you do this, stay calm and neutral. Wait until the dog visibly calms. When you go to remove the dog from time out, he should sit and offer appropriate behavior as he would during kennel routine. The dog does not leave time out until he is ready to do so without resuming the behavior. If a time out is impossible, you can stop and step on the leash, turning your back towards the dog. If you do this, make sure that you have the end of the leash secure in your hand and that the amount of leash the dog has is sufficient to stop the mouthing but not so short that their neck is being pulled taut or downward.
In addition to handling mouthing in the moment, it is important to work with dogs exhibiting this behavior on self-control games, give them appropriate outlets for chewing (and frustration), engage in calming exercises, and teach them to use all of their senses to explore through things like puzzle toys and nose work.
This is exactly what it sounds like and will be handled similarly to mouthing. An important thing to remember with leash biters is that you DO NOT want to engage in a game of tug. This can reinforce and escalate the behavior. For dogs who are NOT redirection biters, dropping the leash and getting a secure hold of their harness will stop the behavior. If you are not holding the leash, they have no friction against which to tug. You may also choose to use two leashes so that you can drop one and switch between them or slip a length of pvc pipe over the leash so the dog is unable to grab hold of it. It helps to hold the leash lower (keep your hands near your hips) so the leash is less tempting as it’s not as likely to pass near the dog’s face or be above them.
Though leash biting sometimes really is just a play behavior, leash biting, and leash “climbing” in particular, are often caused by significant kennel stress. In addition to the exercises for mouthy dogs, de-escalate this behavior by:
- Spending time in the kennel to build a positive association with that space,
- Making kennel routine solid so your interaction takes on a calmer, more focused direction, and
- Providing plenty of enrichment that includes time away from the shelter environment.
- Teach the dog to carry a toy in their mouth as an incompatible behavior.
Respect what the reactive dog is seeing. S/he is not wrong.
Some reactivity is normal dog reaction misclassified as problem behavior. The dog who is responding appropriately to another dog’s or human’s rudeness is not a dog who is in the wrong.
If the dog’s response seems out of proportion for the stimulus, that doesn’t mean that it isn’t a valid experience for that dog. For most reactive dogs, their reactions occur only if they see the other dog/person as a threat. It is their lack of social skills that means they sometimes misread other dogs/people or respond too quickly without sufficient avoidance behaviors. However, dismissing what the dog is seeing does nothing to help the dog. We must respect what they perceive if we are to identify triggers and give them the skills they need to better handle themselves.
When working with a reactive shelter dog in the kennel environment, be sure to choose the path of least resistance. The shelter is an unnatural setting that creates reactivity through barrier frustration and the feeling that the dogs have nowhere to retreat from the abundance of barking, stress, and relative chaos. We can help shelter dogs (those in kennels as well as the dog we’re handling) by limiting their opportunity to practice this behavior as much as we can.
Here are some of our favorite techniques for helping reactive dogs that you will likely see as part of individual dog training plans:
- BAT: Behavior Adjustment Training. This is particularly effective for anxious or fearful dogs and is a skill you’ll learn in our reactive dog seminar. Dogs learn socially appropriate behavior to replace the reaction by using functional rewards based on the dog’s own needs. We love that it relies on the dog making choices and genuinely learning replacement behaviors and social skills, rather than being heavily managed by the handler.
- Parallel Work. This is simply engaging in activities that the dog enjoys at a safe distance from the stimulus and, just like with BAT, working to decrease that threshold while allowing the dog to choose appropriate behaviors and build social skills. It can be literally anything from training games, scent work, TTouch or other relaxation activities, a formal group class, or even just a group walk or hike. In fact, we incorporate group hikes and walks with our reactive dogs regularly because they can be such a positive learning experience in a fun, low-pressure context.
- LAT: Look at That! This is one that works well for all subsets of reactivity from the fearful dog to the squirrel or bike chaser. The dog is rewarded for looking at the stimulus and then back at you. It’s not just the activity, but the philosophy behind it that we really appreciate. Like the above two activities, the dog is fully aware of the stimulus and learns to make a positive choice while building a positive association with the stimulus.
Fear-Based Reluctant/Shutdown Behavior
These dogs may have any number of reasons for their behavior and we don’t often know what it is. This could apply to feral or semi-feral dogs, long-term strays, backyard or chained dogs, dogs who have been abused or attacked, dogs who are seriously undersocialized, or even dogs who are exceptionally sensitive to the shelter environment. The common behaviors under this umbrella are pancaking, freezing, refusal to walk on leash, refusal or reluctance to interact, flinching/hand-shy, trembling or shaking, tail-tucked crouched walking posture, retreating or trying to escape (flight response engaged), and even displays of defensive fear aggression including growling, teeth baring, and air snapping.
When working with these dogs, patience is a must. We cannot ask more of them than they are able to give us. It can be hard to sit patiently and let a dog come to you. However, putting pressure on these dogs will often backfire and risks serious regression & escalation of fear-based behaviors. Moderate your body language to be as non-threatening and inviting as possible and let the dog come to you. Treat/Retreat is a perfect game to play with fearful dogs, as is doing something as simple as sitting with them in their kennels and reading or talking softly. You can slowly introduce them to things like the leash and toys by placing them in the dog’s range and letting them sniff and explore at their own pace.
If you are out on a walk with one of these dogs and they pancake or freeze, come down to their level and use your voice and soft body language to encourage them along. Move a few paces in the direction they wish to go and then gently curve back the way you were headed. Avoid putting tension on the leash; instead gently stroke your fingers along the leash in the direction you’d like the dog to go.
Use positive experiences to help build the dog’s confidence. TTouch, including work on the obstacle course, is a great tool for fearful dogs. Continue offering a variety of toys and tasty treats even if the dog is not initially interested. As you interact with these dogs and discover something they like and respond well to, share that information!
For the purpose of this training, we use “barrier frustration” to refer to dogs whose reactivity and stress behaviors are largely specific to their kennel. This can mean barking, lunging, and even biting at the kennel door, or showing behaviors like spinning, gate climbing, or wall climbing/jumping. We need to give these dogs an outlet for their stress and an appropriate way to redirect their frustration when people/other dogs pass by their kennel.
Gate games as described above are one excellent way to curb this behavior, as is taking the time to work on a solid kennel routine. It is also necessary to work on this behavior from inside the kennel with the dog to stop the habit and de-escalate frustration by:
- Talking in a casual, upbeat voice, giving the dog tasty treats, and/or engaging in fun activities as other people or dogs pass by the kennel.
- Teach the dog to redirect that behavior onto a toy by giving them a toy to hold and praising them as they do so each time people/dogs pass by.
- Working the Relaxation Protocol inside the kennel.
- Ensuring that barrier frustrated dogs have access to varied enrichment toys inside their kennels at all time.
- Focusing on quality downtime with the dog to help them relax inside their kennel.
Some dogs learned before they arrived at the shelter that there is no good reason for them to engage with humans. Some have simply never had the chance. Some start to disassociate after a long time in the shelter as a coping mechanism. The type of behavior we are talking about here is common to backyard/chained dogs. This isn’t just the excited dog who has trouble focusing. This is the dog who just doesn’t care very much about you, perhaps beyond some mild curiosity about the meaty smell in your pocket. He doesn’t trust you and he doesn’t have any good reason to listen to you. Our job is to give him one.
We build relationships with each of the dogs we work with, but in this case we have to show the dog the value of that relationship. Sure, treats are great and a good way to get the ball rolling, but we need to find activities these dogs enjoy and use them to build trust, respect, and engagement. Experiment with games, toys, going for a jog, sniffing stuff, car rides, field trips, etc. Work in Doggie Zen and generously reward eye contact and checking in. Make loose leash walking a priority to help the dog connect (You want to get there? We are going together.), and work on touch, not just TTouch but affection, connecting, and acclimating the dog to being handled.
These can be some of the hardest dogs to get adopted (they ignore adopters and come off as less than warm and fuzzy) but they are often some of the best dogs we get to meet. They have big personalities and life is often an epic adventure of discovery once they learn to connect and engage.
Understanding Threshold, http://suzanneclothier.com/system/files/articles_pdf/Understanding%20Thresholds.pdf
Further Suggested Reading
DOL’s Supplemental Training Plans & Workshops, http://www.dogsoutloud.org/behavior-resources/shelter-programming/